Friday, 20 November 2026

The battle over the Scythians - the weaponisation of history by Elisabeth Storrs


Over millennia, history has been weaponised to justify conquest. Examples of this are the invasion of the Soviet Union by the Nazis, and Russia’s current war in Ukraine. Bizarrely, in both instances, the aggressors argue their assaults are defensible by asserting descendancy from the ancient Scythians entitles the reclamation of ‘ancestral lands’.

Who exactly were the Scythians?

The Scythians were nomadic people of Iranic origin who migrated in the C9th BCE from Central Asia (‘the Stans’) to the Caucasus, Ukraine, Crimean Peninsula and Russia. By the C7th BCE they controlled the Pontic steppes in a land the Greeks called ‘Scythia’. The Scythians maintained dominance in the region before they were supplanted by the nomadic Sarmatians in C2nd BCE and, ultimately, by the Ostro-Goths. A fierce warrior people, they were famous for their equestrian skills, particularly their mastery of mounted archery. Over time, their nomadic lifestyle incorporated a semi sedentary aspect where they practiced farming but moved periodically for seasonal or resource needs. They also established a trading network with Greek colonies along the Black Sea.

The Scythians left no written records. Their history comes from secondary sources such as Akkadian cuneiform texts from Mesopotamia, but primarily from ancient Greek writers. In his Histories, C5th BCE historian, Herodotus of Halicarnassus, wrote extensively on Scythian culture, customs and history although it is not known whether he actually ever visited Scythia. It should be noted Herodotus is entertaining, but not always reliable, because he weaves mythology, gossip and fact into his accounts. He painted the Scythians as courageous and determined, but also brutal and savage, allegedly drinking blood, scalping their enemies and conducting human sacrifice.

The bravery and hardiness of the Scythians was evidenced by their success against the might of the Persian empire when King Darius attempted to conquer Scythia in 513 BCE (supposedly in retribution for the Scythians seizing areas of Iran a century earlier). Outnumbered and militarily inferior, the Scythian tribes united to resist the invasion using unconventional tactics. They avoided open battles with the Persian army by luring the invaders to chase them deep into their territory. They then employed scorched earth tactics that left Scythia devastated but deprived the Persians of any effective triumph. Eventually, the Persians abandoned their attempts, frustrated by guerilla raids and the elusiveness of their enemy. Yet such is the way of contested history, Darius recorded his campaign as a victory by listing the Scythians as conquered peoples on his famous tomb inscription at Naqsh-e Rostam. There is no archaeological evidence to suggest the Persians controlled any Scythian territory but it interesting to note that Darius ‘writing in stone’ he defeated the Scythians only served as propaganda for his own people. The David and Goliath tale also echoes the defiance and resolve of modern Ukrainians to fight for their land, no matter the cost.

Why claim the Scythians as forebears?

The concept of Russians descending from the Scythians arose in the C18th when Catherine the Great postulated the Scythians were the forefathers of Slavic tribes. The linkage between the ancient people to Russian nationalism continued into the C19th. A literary and cultural movement known as ‘Scythianism’ emerged where intellectuals sought to embrace Russian identity as both Asiatic and European. They idealised the Scythians in art and poetry as ferocious, untamed warriors living in harmony in the natural world compared to Western Europeans who sought to impose societal decorum. Alexander Pushkin, reputedly Russia’s greatest poet, wrote:

‘Now temperance is not appropriate,

I want to drink like a savage Scythian.’

The differentiation of Russian raw spirit from western decadence continued during the Soviet period. Disturbingly, today, a far-Right ultranationalist group calling itself the ‘New Scythians’ subscribe to the ideology of ‘Eurasianism’ that seeks to restore Russian dominance over its neighbours in ‘Eurasia’, especially Ukraine.

The fight over the Scythian gold

The most impressive archaeological finds revealing Scythian culture are superb golden artefacts found in burial mounds (kurgans) scattered across the Pontic steppes. These ceremonial helmets, weapons and jewellery depict intricate scenes of real and mythological humans and animals. The most prized example is a magnificent golden pectoral from the Tovsta Mohyla kurgan, discovered in 1971 near the city of Pokrov. No distinction of ownership between Russia and Ukraine from any excavations were made until Ukraine gained independence as a state in 1991. Thereafter, Putin and the Russian Federation denied Ukraine’s right to exist and the independence of Ukrainian culture from Russia. Yet the Scythians are indisputably part of the history of both nations.

Putin has actively taken up the baton to pin Russian identity to the Scythians, too. This has taken the form of a lengthy legal dispute over a collection of 500 plus exhibits from Crimean museums that were lent to the Allard Pierson Museum in Amsterdam and became trapped there after the Russian Federation annexed Crimea in 2014. Ukraine sought return of the treasure as it claims sovereignty over Crimea. The Russians staked their own claim based on contested history as to ownership of the peninsula. The Dutch court of appeal’s final decision to return all the
exhibits to Ukraine has provoked outrage in Russia.

The Nazis and the Scythians

In my novel, Fables & Lies, I explore Heinrich Himmler’s ‘Master Plan’ which included the weaponisation of history to justify the invasion, occupation and settlement of eastern territories including Russia, Ukraine and the Caucasus. Archaeologists and prehistorians from Himmler’s research institute, the SS Ahnenerbe, built on prior nationalist ideology to assert ‘Indo-Germanics’ arose in northern Germany and Scandinavia in the Stone Age then spread their culture across the world seeding all great civilisations including, Greece, Rome and Persia. The rest of the world saw these Indo-Germanics or proto-Indo-Aryans (now known as Proto-Indo-Europeans) emerging in the east. Based on pernicious racial theories, German nationalist and Nazi prehistorians argued ‘base races’ had diluted pure blood Aryans other than those in Nordic and Germanic regions who constituted the ‘Master Race’. Himmler even harboured a fancy that primordial Aryans were survivors of the sinking of Atlantis, a great northern land which sank in a cataclysmic deluge, with some ‘super-humans’ surviving on unsubmerged highlands such as the Himalayas, Bolivian Andes and Canary Islands.

The Germans were also involved in wholesale looting of Scythian artefacts from museums in Ukraine and Crimea throughout WW2 although Himmler and
Hitler believed other Slavic cultural assets were substandard and ordered artwork, palaces and libraries to be destroyed, including the Alexander Palace and Tolstoy’s estate.

The doctrine of the spread of Indo-Germanics was taught in schools during the Third Reich and promulgated to the public by Goebbels through his Department of Propaganda and Enlightenment. The Ahnenerbe embedded prehistorians with troops in Russia and Ukraine to indoctrinate ordinary soldiers to believe they were the descendants of the Scythians and the Ostro-Goths. As such they were entitled to vanquish, dispossess and murder Slavic people as part of a ‘home-coming’. It is therefore ironic the Nazis and ultra-right Russians both assert Scythian ancestry given they argue from diametrically opposing positions. And even more ironic is the fact Slavic and Germanic peoples are all descended from the first Proto-Indo-European culture which emerged in the Stone Age from - guess where? The Pontic-Caspian steppes in Ukraine! How very tragic that history not only records bloodshed and war but causes them.

PS – On a brighter note, here’s a bit of trivia. Ever wondered who the woman on the Starbucks logo is? She is Mixoparthenos, a part-woman, part-snake goddess who was worshipped by Scythians and considered to be the mythological ancestor of the Scythian race. I wonder what the fierce steppe warriors would make of their deity’s image gracing the side of a coffee cup!

Elisabeth Storrs is the author of the A Tale of Ancient Rome series. Her latest release, is Fables & Lies: A World War II Novel about stolen Trojan treasure and the Aryan Myth. She is also the founder of the Historical Novel Society Australasia and the ARA Historical Novel Prize. Learn more at www.elisabethstorrs.com.  

Images are from Wikimedia Commons - Scythian gold comb depicting battle scene C4th BCE, Scythian warrior marble bas relief C4th-2nd BCE (Ukraine),  Tovsta Mohyl pectoral C4th BCE (Ukraine),  gold ceremonial helmet C4th BCE (Ukraine), statue of Mixoparthenos C2nd CE (Crimea)

Thursday, 12 November 2026

Cowslips in the Morn.

I must go seek dewdrops here

      And hang a pearl in every cowslip’s ear.

       

      Shakespeare’s poem sang in her mind, opening the door to a vision of Amy in 1560. Her imagined Amy. Strolling alone in a golden meadow, she did not look a woman in her late twenties, but a fragile, too-slender, ill girl. A girl lost.

      The real Amy Dudley must have lived long years of a lonely life, and years of pain. Lucy trembled. Not just physical pain. Amy Dudley must have felt so rejected in the last months of her life.

      The faint apricot scent of cowslips wafted on the breeze. The cowslip meadow scene in her novel opened in Lucy’s mind. Amy had come to Oxford to visit friends. She had not seen Robert Dudley, her husband, for months. Drifting in the meadow with a light footfall, Amy clasped in one hand the green stem of a cowslip flower and in the other, a buttercup. She held the flowers before her like a sacred offering.

    (SHADES OF YELLOW). 


I have lost count of the moments when the act of writing and the words it births on the white page makes me ponder about what is actually going on. And there’s so much going on. First, there’s the magic of surrendering to writing. Then there’s experience of being channelled — of being a scribe to the voices in my head. Most of my writing grows from what I describe as my writing compost — the sum of everything I know and have experienced in life — but there are also magical moments in writing that have me floundering to understand what is going on in my subconscious, if not deepening my belief in ancestral memory.

With Shades of Yellow, my most recent novel, I crafted something different from my usual works of historical fiction. My story is about an Australian woman of British ancestry (like I am) who is writing a Tudor novel. Sounds biographical, doesn’t it? But while my life experience gives me plenty to tap into for this work, my character’s story differs from mine. And it differs by a lot. My imagined Aussie Lucy is young and going through one of those challenging times in life that I can only describe as ticking off that writerly advice of placing our characters up a tree and then throwing stones at them. And in amid of writing this work, I found Lucy, then in England, seeing flowering cowslips here and there.  

 It was when I wrote ‘Amy held the flowers out before her like a sacred offering’ my curiosity became really aroused — and I disappeared down into a research burrow to find out more about cowslips.  

I never expected to find cowslips (a name believed originating from the fact that they used to grow in pastures where cows grazed and left their calling card of cow pats) — so fascinating — or that they were indeed a sacred offering in ancient times. Druids believed in the magical powers of cowslips and used them for remedies — and also likely excellent remedies because both flowers and leaves are rich in vitamin C.

The Vikings offered cowslips to the goddess Freya, known as their Key Virgin. They also believed the flowers doubled as a key to Freya’s palace. This later led to Christians taking hold of this mythology and Freya changed into the Virgin Mary and cowslips gained the name of Our Lady’s Keys or Key of Heaven. Cowslips also have other names associated with keys, and magical keys too: St. Peter’s Keys (from a legend about the flowers growing where an annoyed St Peter dropped the keys of Heaven) and password, as well as being known as Palsywort, Cowslop, Fair Bells and Fairy Cup.

Considering the plant has been used to treat headaches, insomnia, spasms, cramps, asthma, coughs, bruising and even kidney problems, it is not surprising that the flower has a strong association with healing.

In Midsummer’s Night Dream, Shakespeare provides for us with insights into how people from his time viewed these beautiful bright yellow flowers, which long ago bloomed in spring and early summer in so many places in England:

 

Over hill, over dale,

Thorough bush, thorough brier,

Over park, over pale,

Thorough flood, thorough fire,

I do wander everywhere,

Swifter than the moon’s sphere;

And I serve the fairy queen,

To dew her orbs upon the green:

The cowslips tall her pensioners be;

In their gold coats spots you see;

Those be rubies, fairy favours,

In those freckles live their savours:

 must go seek some dewdrops here

And hang a pearl in every cowslip’s ear.

Farewell, thou lob of spirits: I’ll be gone;

Our queen and all her elves come here anon.

 

Wish for fairy treasure? Easy — just find a field of cowslips. If you find one, after decades when cowslips struggled for survival and cowslip fields became a rare sight to behold, regard the field as treasure indeed. Know any fairies who need to escape danger or bad weather? Cowslip bells offer them the perfect refuge. The flower bells even provide for fairies a cup to collect dew for their morning drink.  


People once believed that wearing a bunch of cowslips helped keep you young. The flowers are a vital ingredient for a spell to improve one’s complexion. Which makes me wonder if the recipe Culpeper gives for a cosmetic made from cowslip flowers and distilled water may have originated from this spell. He writes:

 

‘Our city dames know well enough the ointment or distilled water of it adds to beauty or at least restores it when lost. The flowers are held to be more effectual than the leaves and the roots of little use. An ointment being made with them taketh away spots and wrinkles of the skin, sunburnings and freckles and promotes beauty; they remedy all infirmities of the head coming of heat and wind, as vertigo, false apparitions, phrensies, falling sickess, palsies, convulsions, cramps, pains in the nerves, and the roots ease pains in the back and bladder. The leaves are good in wounds and the flowers take away trembling. Because they strengthen the brains and nerves and remedy palsies, the Greeks gave them the name Paralysio. The flowers preserved or conserved and a quantity the size of a nutmeg taken every morning is a sufficient dose for inward diseases, but for wounds, spots, wrinkles and sunburnings an ointment is made of the leaves and hog’s lard’ 1

 

Cowslips were used to celebrate the pagan festival of Beltane with its strong connection to fertility—which later evolved to Mayday celebrations when they decorated the May Pole with cowslips. It was common practice for people to grow or place cowslips from their doors to keep fairies out, as well as receive a fairy blessing on their home, and they also burnt cowslips on Mayday to keep fairies away.

 I speculate that Beltane rituals are the reason farmers continued the practice of crush cowslip leaves to make a juice to brush on their cows’ udders to stop fairies and witches or anything just as annoying from stealing their milk. Farmers also believed cowslips protected their cows from fairies—as well as evil spirits and witches.

Unsurprisingly, with its connection to Beltane, it seems cowslips were once an ingredient in love portions. Children also bunched the flowers tightly into a ball (called a totsie), which they tossed, chanting “Titsy, totsy, tell me true, who shall I be married to?” 2

As an Australian, I was at first amazed to find cowslips appearing in my story. But the more I thought about it, and the more I discovered about cowslips, the more I delighted in including them. I wanted to write a story with an optimistic ending; what better flower — a flower once seen as the symbol for new life after months of winter and the ‘Healer of the World’  3. — for me to use?

Their existence in Shades of Yellow now makes far better sense to me. Cowslips are as much a part of my DNA as the springtime flower of the Australian wattle. With my DNA rooted in Britain for centuries, I confess that cowslips grow far deeply in my ancestral memory to play with in my storytelling. Or perhaps I am simply drawing from my unconscious mind long forgotten lines from my teenage love of reading Shakespeare:  

 

Where the bee sucks, there suck I,

In a cowslip’s bell I lie;

There I couch when owls do cry;

On the bat’s back I do fly

After summer merrily.

Merrily, merrily shall I live now

Under the blossom that hangs on the bough.

 

Whatever it is, writing is pure magic.


 

 

 

 1/ https://inlanding.wordpress.com/2013/12/03/flora-along-the-oxford-canal-cowslips/

 

 

 2/ Cowslips [2] http://thegowercoast2008.blogspot.com/2009/09/cowslips.html

Anne Mcintyre

https://annemcintyre.com/2022/02/28/cowslip/



3/ Himmelschlüssel Cowslip [3] - the awakening

http://www.tirolerreine.at/en/varieties/cowslip.html



 

 

 

 

 

Sources used:


Do cowslips have magical qualities?

 

https://jardindesign.org/2014/04/05/cowslips-primula-veris/

 

Cowslip (Primula veris) a Sacred Druid Herb

https://southcowichanexplorer.wordpress.com/2016/03/17/fairy-bells-primula-veris-a-sacred-druid-herb/

 

Ultimate Guide to Cowslip Flowers (Primula veris)

https://www.petalrepublic.com/cowslip-flowers/

 

Cowslip 

https://www.botanical.com/botanical/mgmh/c/cowsl112.html

 

Primula veris (officinalis) Cowslip

https://www.alchemy-works.com/primula_veris.html


Cowslips  http://thegowercoast2008.blogspot.com/2009/09/cowslips.html

Anne Mcintyre

https://annemcintyre.com/2022/02/28/cowslip/

 

Celebrating-the-cowslip-on-may-day-morning-in-the-witchs-garden

https://www.gothichorrorstories.com/witches-garden/witch-garden-feature/witches-garden-plants/celebrating-the-cowslip-on-may-day-morning-in-the-witchs-garden/

 

Witchcraft and the Day-to-Day: Experiences of a London Witch

http://www.badwitch.co.uk/2013/04/cowslips-beauty-among-beasts.html


Himmelschlüssel Cowslip - the awakening

http://www.tirolerreine.at/en/varieties/cowslip.html


William Shakespeare, A Midsummer Night’s Dream, Act 2 Scene 1.


William Shakespeare, The Tempest, Act V, Scene I 



 

Images are Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

 








Friday, 6 November 2026

To a Fellow History Girl and Friend by L.J. Trafford



On the 25th October I received some very sad news, Ruth Downie had died. Ruth was the author of the Medicus series of Roman Britain set murder mysteries and a fellow History Girl from 2018-2023. I thought it was fitting that I use my History Girls slot to pay tribute to Ruth.


I had known of Ruth long before I met her in the flesh. I'd read the first of her Medicus series of novels set in Roman Britain, Ruso and the Dancing Girls and enjoyed it so much I waited eagerly for each new installment. Why did I love them so much? Because they are super entertaining and funny. In Ruth's books Romans don't make speeches at each other like they do in those Sword and Sandals films of old, no they have actual conversations with each other. Her characters are believable, human, and identifiable despite living in very different times to ours.

Their tone might have been light, but the Medicus series contained some serious hardcore research. Not that you would notice, too caught up in the story to consciously spot you were in a history lesson. It's a knack that not every historical fiction writer has, to impart detailed information about the period without bombarding the reader with everything you learnt whilst researching; Ruth had the knack.


I admired her writing greatly and I count her, along with Lindsey Davis and Allan Massie, as the writers who most inspired my own Four Emperor Series of novels. All three of them made ancient Rome accessible, human and funny.

I was delighted, nay stunned when the Ruth Downie, author of those books I'd devoured, agreed to write a blurb for the back cover of my first novel, Palatine. I couldn't believe that a writer of her calibre and success would take the time to read a book from a very small publisher written by a complete unknown who'd never had anything published before. But she did.

Shortly afterwards we were both attendees at the Historical Novel Society Annual Conference. This was my first step as a published author into the writing world. I had a horrible attack of imposter syndrome the moment I looked at anyone's name badge and realised I was chatting to a proper author, a proper writer, one whose books I had seen in actual shops and reviewed in newspapers. Why on earth were they bothering to talk to me?
Ruth (credit to her own website)


Queuing up for the toilets, cringing behind yet another proper writer whose books I had read, I heard a cheery voice enquire, "LJ Trafford?" It was Ruth exiting the loos and having spotted my name badge she stopped for a chat. Now the queue for the ladies is not the most glamourous of locations to hold a conversation but Ruth took the time to recount how she'd been searching for me so she could to tell me face to face that she'd enjoyed reading my book. I was taken aback by this gesture, how kind and generous it was.
I came to learn that this was Ruth all over, supportive, kind and generous to her fellow writers, when we became members of the same gang.
Ruth sitting opposite LJ Trafford, Alison Morton & Alex Gough



I've always wanted to be part of a gang, not an inner city, county lines style one, because I've seen 24 Hours in Police Custody and no good ever comes of it, but rather a gang of pals, of likeminded people who get together for a specific purpose, each member bringing a specific skill set. 

There's your solving mysteries gang such as Scooby-Doo and his human friends. Velma bringing brains, Daphne bringing beauty, Fred bringing the brawn and Shaggy bringing the scoobie snacks (because somebody had to). Elsewhere inspired by Scooby-Doo (and which of us can truly say that we weren't) Joss Wheedon created the Scooby Gang for hit TV Series Buffy the Vampire Slayer. The Scoobies fought vampires and other supernatural beasties whilst making terribly witty quips in a way that 17-year-olds never have in the history of all time.

Children's literature and TV are full of gangs from Enid Blyton's Famous Five and Secret Seven to the Harry Potter trio of Harry, Ron and the girl one. Musicals have provided with memorable and unthreatenIng gangs prone to bursting into songs, such as Pink Ladies and The T Byrds from Grease.

Even the ultimate anti-social introvert, Sherlock Holmes got in on the gang scene with the Baker Street irregulars. Gangs are everywhere.


It was not until my 40s that I got my wish to be part of a gang. Our common bond was that we all really liked ancient Rome. We liked it so much we'd all written books about it and we travelled about the country standing in tents behind trestle tables piled high with those books we'd written in ex-Roman towns like York, Colchester and Leicester. There were six core members (although many others were suckered into our orbit) SJA (Simon) Turney & his wife Tracey (arch organiser and bringer of sandwiches), Alex Gough, Alison Morton, Ruth Downie and me.

  
Authors not in a tent for once. Ruth is on the far left



We each brought our own skill set in the type of books we write, they may all have ancient Rome in common but between us we have produced mystery stories, adventure tales, books set amongst the legions, in the provinces, in the Emperors court and in a modern day Roman Empire that didn't fall.
Here again I witnessed Ruth's generosity in action as she directed the crowd of fans crowding her stall to 'check out LJ's books'.
An authors tent before the punters arrive



Although we only met up at most maybe two or three times a year we were the gang I'd always wanted to belong to. We hung around in those authors tents moaning about the state of publishing, sharing gossip, buying each other's latest book and scrawling a personal dedication in them. We sat on panels working together to field questions from super Roman enthusiasts. We had long meals together in the evening chatting away for hours.


In-between festivals we were still a gang, promoting each others books, writing reviews and blurbs, recommending each other for speaking or writing gigs, helping each other in any way we could.


It was a great gang to be a member of and Ruth was at its heart. I will never forget Ruth's kindness to my Mum when she accompanied me to the York Eboracum Festival. She chatted away to her, putting her at ease in the sometimes strange world of Roman festivals, making her feel welcome. As we were all packing up our stuff at the end of the Festival Ruth came over and said to my Mum, "Of course you will be coming to Colchester, Christine." My Mum had just been anointed as a gang member.


Authors and tent, again



Rest in peace Ruth, and thank you for the support you freely offered , your generosity of spirit, for the fun and the laughter and for Valens, who was always my favourite character in the Medicus books even though I know he is a horrible person in many ways

On the bill



Buy Ruth's books here   
L.J. Trafford



L.J. Trafford writes about Romans alot and Greeks a little. Amazon.co.uk: L. J. Trafford: books, biography, latest update











Friday, 30 October 2026

A snippet of Scotland's History (after Bayeux) by Margaret Skea

A snippet of Scotland’s History in Tapestry (after Bayeux)

There has been a great deal of excitement and media attention focused on the loan of the Bayeux Tapestry to the British Museum in London – the first time this tapestry has been on display in the UK since it was made. It is believed to have been commissioned in the 1070s by Bishop Odo of Bayeux, who was the half-brother of William the Conqueror, and tells the story of the conquest of England culminating in the Battle of Hastings in 1066. The tapestry is 70metres long, but despite its name is actually an embroidery, stitched in wool on linen, and though the perspective of the story is French, it is believed to have been stitched in England in the Canterbury area. 

In the late 1800s a lady called Elizabeth Wardle, the founder of the Leek Embroidery Society, following a visit to France, felt that England should have its own copy of the tapestry.  Using drawings of the original, Elizabeth and 35 other women, many of whom were members of the Leek Society stitched a copy, replicating the woollen threads of the original.  Each panel carried the name of the lady who stitched it with Elizabeth’s name at the end and the date of completion  - 1886. As a community arts project it was a success and today it has a permanent home in Reading Museum.          


The beginning section of the replica tapestry. 
              

Fast forward to 2010 when the author Alexander McCall Smith, having seen the tapestry depicting the battle of Prestonpans, and perhaps thinking also of the Bayeux Tapestry, initiated the ambitious idea of a tapestry which would present the history of Scotland from the Ice Age to the present day. In collaboration with author Alistair Moffat, who agreed to write the historical narrative and artist Andrew Crummie, commissioned to draw the panels; the community arts project called the Great Tapestry of Scotland was born. Like the Bayeux it is actually an embroidery, but using wools. Stitching began in the spring of 2012 and it was unveiled at the Scottish parliament in September 2013.

It has 160 panels, and is over 130 metres long and has been stitched by more than 1000 volunteers from all over Scotland.  Each panel depicts a significant historical event, movement or period in Scotland’s history. The group I joined was given the panel depicting ‘The Border Reivers and the Rescue of Kinmont Willie’. This was the panel as we received it – leaving space for us to add to the initial design. 

   


                                                         

But who were the ‘reivers’ and why are they significant in the history of Scotland?

They were ‘a people who lived beyond the laws of England and Scotland, who ignored the persistent efforts of central government to impose order, who took their social form and norms from the ancient conventions of tribalism, who invented ever more sophisticated variants on theft, cattle rustling, murder and extortion…

…And they spoke and sang beautiful, sad poetry and told a string of stirring, unforgettable stories.’

Alistair Moffat: ‘The Reivers’

Many of the notable ‘reiver’ surnames including Armstrong, Elliot, Graham, Scott, Johnstone, Kerr and Maxwell are still common in the Scottish Borders today.

Central to the reivers’ activities was an area delightfully termed the ‘Debatable Land’. Straddling the border between Scotland and England, for over 300 years its inhabitants effectively answered to neither government.

Beyond the Debatable Land a wide stretch of territory on both sides of the notional ‘border’ was divided into ‘marches’ and officials, called ‘wardens’, were appointed by both governments. Thus, for example, there was a warden of the English middle march and a corresponding warden of the Scottish middle march. Equally disregarded by the reiving families, the wardens sometimes co-operated across the border in seeking to maintain order.

Customary law forbade the building of any permanent dwelling in the Debatable Land. But one of the methods used to enforce this was interesting, to say the least. In 1551 the Crown officers of England and Wales made the declaration:

‘All Englishmen and Scottishmen, after this proclamation made, are and shall be free to rob, burn, spoil, slay, murder and destroy all and every such persons, their bodies, buildings, goods and cattle as do remain or shall inhabit upon any part of the said Debatable Land without any redress to be made of the same.’

More likely to add to rather than reduce the lawlessness, it didn’t clear the area of inhabitants: one notable family: the Grahams, who were present in large numbers on both sides of the border, are known to have had five tower houses there and they were not the only ones.

The sandstone tower on our panel (the part that I embroidered) depicts one of the Armstrong fortified houses – Gilnockie – belonging to Johnnie Armstrong, hung on the order of James V along with thirty or forty (depending on which account you believe) of his followers at Carlanrig, near Hawick.


The circumstances are unclear of what seems summary justice (all the records state that they were hung on growing trees rather than gallows), though it was likely to have been an impulsive and possibly dishonourable act. 

One result was a spawning of ballads that turned a ruthless thug into a Robin Hood figure of almost heroic proportions.

 


                                                                    

The grey tower on the opposite side represents Hermitage, an isolated but imposing castle, home to James Hepburn, Lord Bothwell, who later became Mary Queen of Scots’ third husband.

In 1552 a compromise solution to the vexed issue of jurisdiction was proposed – to draw a straight line from east to west where Armstrong and Graham land met. The result was the building of ‘ The Scots Dyke’: a four-mile long earthwork approximately nine feet wide and eight feet high. It would have been hard to miss, but whether it had any positive effect is another matter. Especially as it wouldn’t take very long on horseback to ride around either end!

Far from the wardens being in control of the borderland, it was the heads of local clans who were the authority, their power in proportion to their numerical strength. Which in some cases was considerable – George Macdonald Fraser, in his book ‘The Steel Bonnets’, suggests that the Armstrongs alone could muster 3000 men. Not a force to be lightly challenged.

The number of reivers involved in an individual raid, would of course be much smaller, but still considerable, typically anything from thirty to around a hundred men. In the centre of our panel are two reivers wearing their normal garb of steel bonnets (hence Fraser’s book title) and padded jerkins,

 

                                                  





                             

                                   
the sheep and cattle imprisoned in their gauntleted fists, symbolizing their core activities of cattle-rustling and sheep-stealing.

Seeing a hundred or more of them thundering across the moor towards your door, one hand on the reins, the other holding the long spears that flank the panel, must have been a terrifying sight.

Interestingly the three-year-old grandchild of one of the ladies involved in sewing the panel stared at them for a moment, then said, before running away, ‘I don’t like those men’.

An instinctive reaction that may be an echo of hundreds of children before her.

The ‘Day of Truce’ mentioned in one of the scrolls at the top of the panel, was a day when Scots and English came together to witness the trials of criminals from both sides of the border. The jury comprised six Scots – chosen by the English; and six English – chosen by the Scots. There were agreed penalties for perjury by witnesses, an attempt at ensuring honest testimony; interestingly the most important and effective wasn’t a fine or imprisonment, but a formal statement that no future testimony would be accepted or believed. Honour among thieves was a part of the reiver code. All witnesses and those who came to the Truce were to be given safe conduct through others’ territory and were honour-bound to refrain from confrontation and not to offend by ‘word, deed or countenance’ as long as the Truce lasted. When large numbers of sworn enemies attended, it isn’t surprising that tempers often frayed, the wardens struggling to maintain order. What is surprising is that most, though not all, Truce Days appear to have passed without major incident.

Although the main design of each panel was done by a wonderful artist called Andrew Crummy, each group was allowed some input. In our case it was the mane and raindrop infill on the horses and most of the wording, shown in the finished version below. 



 The curse which links the two reivers:

‘I curse their heid and all the haris of their heid’

comes from the ‘Great Monition of Cursing against the Border Reivers’ by Gavin Dunbar, Archbishop of Glasgow 1525 – a lengthy and comprehensive ‘cursing’, which should have put the fear of God into all who heard it.

The quotation at the foot of the panel:

‘My hands are tied but my tongue is free and who will dare this deed avow’

comes from ‘The Ballad of Kinmont Willie.’

At sixty-six Willie had, by the time of his capture, been reiving successfully for some fifty years and led a notorious gang called ‘Kinmont’s Bairns’.


                                                             

While his imprisonment in Carlisle castle was undoubtedly deserved, given a lifetime of crime, his seizure was illegal – captured on his way home from a Truce Day in March 1596. One month later a carefully planned and perfectly executed plan to rescue him was carried out by Scott of Buccleugh, himself a law officer on the Scottish side. Buccleugh had first protested the illegality of the capture and requested Willie’s release, but when this was denied, he acted. A clear indication of the flexible attitude to reiving among border folk, even those appointed to uphold the law.

He rode on Carlisle castle and with a small party of men entered the castle by a locked postern door, having levered out the stone in which the bolt was shot. Without discovery or a shot being fired they spirited Willie away – a daring rescue that was to be one of the last significant border raids.

Sir Walter Scott’s ‘The Minstrelsy of the Scottish Border’ brought together many of the ballads, including that of Kinmont Willie, along with the tunes to which they were sung. Although the tales are often romanticized, they do provide a flavour of the reiving lifestyle and the superstitions and beliefs of the time.

But the writing was on the wall for the reivers. James I’s accession to the English throne in 1603 abolished the border between Scotland and England. Re-naming the area the ‘Middle Shires’ James set in train a dismantling of the reiver way of life and a bringing of law and order to this most unruly part of Great Britain.

The reivers have left their mark on the border landscape in various ways. In the form of innumerable and mostly ruinous tower houses. In literature and music through the Border Ballads. And on tradition, in the annual festivals in all the major and some of the smaller border towns which commemorate the riding of the marches.

They have left their mark too on the English language: the words ‘blackmail’ and ‘bereave’ derive from their activities. A sombre legacy indeed. 

For those wanting to read more on the reivers and this turbulent part of Scottish history, I recommend The Reivers by Alistair Moffat and The Steel Bonnets by George MacDonald Fraser.

And for those interested in seeing the Great Tapestry of Scotland it has a permanent specially built exhibition home in Galashiels in the Scottish Borders - it is well worth a visit, or two, or three...  

Margaret Skea is the award-winning author of three books focusing on a long-running clan feud in Southern Scotland – between the Cunninghame and Montgomerie Clans who certainly followed the principle of robbing, looting and murdering without fear of official redress for many years. I pick up the story at the point when James VI is attempting to subdue the lawlessness and outlaw clan feuds.  Together they comprise the Munro saga:  Turn of the Tide, (Historical Fiction Winner in the Harper Collins People’s Novelist competition and Beryl Bainbridge Best First Time author Award), A House Divided (Long-listed for the Historical Novel Society New Novel Award) and By Sword and Storm. 


They tell the story of a fictional family trapped in the middle of the conflict, with all the challenges and difficulties it poses for their relationships and their safety; along with the pressure it places on conscience and integrity.


For details of these and Margaret’s other books visit www.margaretskea.com 


Ebooks can be found at https://www.amazon.co.uk/stores/Margaret-Skea/author/


                        



 



Friday, 23 October 2026

"Why would anyone go to a play about an economist?’ Author E.J. Barnes, writing about 'The Standard of Living' at Theatre Royal, Haymarket. Introduced by Penny Dolan

As a young, naive London teen, I'd imagined a 'Bloomsbury' world where Virginia got on with her writing and Vanessa her painting, as their lives spread between London squares and that farmhouse with painted walls - and painted everything - in Sussex. Of course, I soon learned of the Stephen's sisters traumatic upbringings, how they both struggled with their work and various relationships.

Then, a few years ago, a shared interest in domestic history brought the author Emma J Barnes and myself together: we were both reading 'Mrs Woolf and the Servants' by Alison Light (Penguin 2007), a non-fiction account of everyday life in the home of the Woolf's and other 'Bloomsbury' names, and  about how they and their servants managed their own 'household economies'. 


 
Among the Bloomsbury Group,  Emma discovered, was John Maynard Keynes: economist, public intellectual, government adviser, financial speculator and connoisseur, and one of the most significant figures of the twentieth century, and whose finances and advice supported others within that set.

Emma, writing as E. J. Barnes, took Keynes as the inspiration for her two remarkable historical novels: MR KEYNES REVOLUTION and MR KEYNES DANCE. As a reader, I found both these novels fascinating and surprising.

                    


As today's date grew closer, I noticed that Keynes was the central character in THE STANDARD OF LIVING, a new play by James Curtis (Dear England) at the Theatre Royal, Haymarket, London. I was keen to know how the subject of economics worked on stage, as might other History Girls and blogpost readers. Even Rory Kinnear, as Maynard Keynes, as the beginning of the play, announces ‘Many of you are feeling daunted by this subject matter.’  

Knowing that Emma was seeing the play, I asked her to share her thoughts her today, both on her two adult novels, and on THE STANDARD OF LIVING play. 




Emma J Barnes wrote:

“I knew about Keynes’ ideas from studying economics, but nothing of his life story, and I soon fell down a rabbit hole of memoir and biography. As I gorged on the struggles of a lost world, I wondered: why had nobody made fiction out of Keynes? His life is significant, colourful and moving: not only did he set the foundations of the postwar order, revolutionise economic theory and transform capitalism, he also made and lost fortunes as a financial speculator, fell in love with a Russian ballerina – Lydia Lopokova – despite having previously lived as a gay man, hid Cezannes in hedges, hobnobbed with everyone who was anybody – including Churchill and Lloyd George, and outraged the establishment time and again while also ending up as Lord Keynes and a Director of the Bank of England. (And breathe.)





Yet nobody wrote about him. At least they did in the form of biographies and articles, but in the literary world of novels, plays and films, which has created almost an industry out of Woolf and Bloomsbury, he only ever appeared as a bit part. Yet he was the Bloomsbury member who actually did, if any of them did, change the world.

So I decided to seize the gauntlet. This was a rich and neglected story, and also one I could tell. I had studied economics, and worked briefly (like Keynes) as a graduate in the British civil service; I knew Cambridge (one of Keynes’ stomping grounds) quite well. Keynes-obsessed, I wrote a film script (a thing I’d always vowed never to do, so few get made), a TV pilot, a stage play, and two novels. I wouldn’t say I got zero interest from the literary gate-keepers, but it was mainly blank faces and unreturned emails, and with the pre-publicity for James Graham’s new play The Standard of Living, I now understand why: because ‘Why would anyone go to a play about an economist?’ was the message that came loud and clear from any journalist reporting on it.

I knew of course that I wouldn’t be the only writer ever to see Keynes’s appeal. In recent years there’s been several novels about Keynes and even a musical. I sometimes avoid others’ versions (I’m working, slowly, on a third Keynes novel) but it’s also at times irresistible to see how other writers tackle the same material, and despite feeling a bit proprietorial, I usually enjoy their versions a lot. James Graham is the celebrated writer of many political dramas, I’ve enjoyed and admired his plays. I bought my ticket and went to London. Here are some thoughts.

THE STANDARD OF LIVING: THE PLAY

I found lots to enjoy in The Standard of Living. Rory Kinnear’s Keynes brought out the humanity and vulnerability of the man wonderfully (maybe slightly less his intellectual firepower: Bertrand Russell said, “When I argued with him, I felt that I took my life in my hands”). Lydia Lopokova’s eccentricity can so easily lapse into caricature, I think – but here she was absolutely spot on and portrayed with great charm by an actual ballerina, Natalia Osipova. The about-turn of Keynes from gay man to her love-lorn suitor was deftly done and the warmth of their relationship beautifully conveyed. The dancing was lovely to watch (though I think there was a missed opportunity to make it more than decorative to which I’ll return) and there was some wonderful wit and humour. It presented a delightful version of Duncan Grant. It did try and get the economics across, with some success (I’ll come back to this). The contemporary photographs moved me, as they always do, in documenting the human catastrophe of the Great Depression. It checked off a lot of the key events of Keynes’ life, although in such a packed life it inevitably left a lot out.

Inevitably I had some reservations. It was a real whistle-stop tour for one thing, crowding thirty plus years into a two hour play. Blink and you miss the battle of the gold standard or Bretton Woods. In this rattling tour of Keynes’ Greatest Hits, Bloomsbury seemed too prominent. Did we really need Lytton Strachey and Dora Carrington and Virginia Woolf and Vanessa Bell and Duncan Grant? Strachey was only significant in the early part of Keynes’ life, Carrington I doubt was significant at all, Woolf and Bell were but it doesn’t really come across in the play why. By contrast, Keynes’s life as statesman, City of London investor, political operator and Cambridge intellectual were underplayed. (And sorry, while those who worked with him may have disliked him, I don’t think they ever got his name wrong!)

There were so few scenes of Keynes thinking, writing or teaching – or smoking for that matter, the usual accompaniment to his intense intellectual work. (Tragically, as if turned out.) There’s no real sense of someone who was wrestling, as he saw it, to completely transform the whole system of economic thought.

“I believe myself to be writing a book on economic theory which will largely revolutionise, not I suppose at once but in the course of the next ten years, the way the world thinks about economic problems.” Keynes in a letter to George Bernard Shaw, 1935.

One scene that jarred for me was when Keynes retreats to Cambridge in the 1930s (and he’d always been rooted in Cambridge, despite what the play implies) and Lydia and Duncan casually suggest that Keynes should write his own General Theory, a bit like Einstein. The title ht deliberately echo Einstein, but Keynes’ attempt to dismantle economic orthodoxy for his academic peers was no impulsive gesture or gimmick. And to suggest that the result was seen as a bit of damp squib compared to Hayek’s very different book, as the play perhaps inadvertently does, is a real distortion I think.
Keynes as Economist

One of the great challenges with fictionalising Keynes (as I know from experience) is how to handle the economics. This play does not sideline it. There’s a rather nice explanation of the multiplier but it’s mainly speech: surely the stage offers a chance to provide visual explanations of the ideas? And with all those lovely dancers!

Here’s how I tried to do this with Lydia’s dancing in Mr Keynes’ Dance.

“She gave him a surprised look then obliged. There, in the winter light from the windows, she lifted her right leg behind her and stretched out her left arm, her chest and head held high, and with the same graceful line proceeding from finger to toe. All was a smooth, poised curve.

Maynard said, ‘Richard, lift her left arm.’

Richard, after a startled second, obeyed. Lydia smoothly adjusted her position to remain still balanced, arms and leg still extended.

‘Now lower her leg.’

‘Go on,’ said Lydia kindly, and so he obediently pushed on an ankle and she readjusted effortlessly.

‘Now give her a good shove.’ And as Richard, taken aback, hesitated: ‘Go on!’

She smiled invitingly at him, so he gave her a push in the small of the back. With the most elegant of jumps she adjusted her position, and resumed her graceful, effortless arabesque. She looked like she could stay there all day.

‘Aha,’ said Maynard, pleased. ‘You see? Lydia is the economic system according to orthodox theory. Every jolt, every shock to the system, and she adjusts at once to reach a new equilibrium. This is the economic system we teach students. The system according to Classical or Neoclassical thinkers.

If Lydia were the economy, there would be no imbalances, no unemployment, no depressions. Richard, stand on one leg.’

‘Me?’

‘Go on! Indulge me.'

Feeling like a prize fool, Richard took Lydia’s place on the hearth rug, then clumsily adopted a version of an arabesque. He felt like an ungainly stork.

‘Lydia, give him a push.’

Very gently, Lydia pushed his raised foot. Richard immediately began to wobble. Unable to regain his balance, he staggered, then toppled onto the hearth.





I was also doubtful about using the conflict with Hayek as the main way of exploring the economic clash of theories. First, it’s not historical: yes, Keynes and Hayek did apparently sit on top of King’s College Chapel doing fire warden duties together during World War II, an irresistible dramatic scene, but I don’t think Keynes ever considered Hayek his key adversary; he was only one of many critical voices in the storm of controversy caused by Keynes’ ideas. Keynes himself seems to have taken a benevolent approach to the younger economist: when Hayek published The Road to Serfdom, he wrote kindly saying that he agreed with much of it.

Keynes, of course, did not know (as we do) that Hayek’s book, published at the end of Keynes’ life, would achieve an almost accidental fame and influence, becoming the the inspiration for the anti-Keynesian Thatcher/Reagan revolution. I say accidental, because what would have happened if it had not by strange quirk of chance been serialised in Reader’s Digest?

More importantly, by setting up Hayek – a young Austrian immigrant – as his opponent, the play obscures the way the economic orthodoxy Keynes attacked was deeply embedded in the British establishment and in the intellectual tradition he inherited. In my book, Montagu Norman, the Governor of the Bank of England, is Keynes’ key adversary, along with Otto Niemeyer of the Treasury. Keynes was battling with the key beliefs and interest of the elites, and he did so at dinner parties with Churchill, hearings at the House of Commons, in the pages of the Liberal Party manifesto, in dining societies in the City of London, in the pages of The Times, and of course in his academic writing. He upset former collaborators and must have felt pangs about what he was doing to the legacy of his own mentor, Alfred Marshall. He was trying to show that not only was laissez-faire – what he called “the economic juggernaut” – inhumane, it was intellectually flawed and potentially disastrous.

There’s little in the play – other than some wonderful photos of the Great Depression – to bring home the people who were at the sharp end of these debates either: for example, the miners who were starved back to work in the 1920s, after Keynes’ advice on the gold standard was ignored. Lydia’s story could have been important here. She was exiled by the Russian Revolution, her brother persecuted by Stalin, her mother dying in the Siege of Leningrad. She was real, living breathing evidence of the suffering caused when a political and economic system collapses. It’s no wonder that she had no patience with those in her circle who flirted with Communism, and I’ve no doubt she strengthened Keynes’ resolve to try and create a more humane capitalism.

Which brings me to a final point: what is at stake in Keynes’ story. The plays says, several times, that Keynes’ primary question was “What is a good life?” Yes, Keynes did address this, notably in his famous essay Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren, and I think Bloomsbury did provide him with his personal model of a “good life” based in friendship and art (perhaps a model that some seeing this play might think inadequate, and late in life he may have agreed).

But I don’t think that was the driving question for him, but a more existential question: How to save civilisation itself. Keynes saw the complacent but peaceful world of his youth destroyed in the Great War; at the Paris Peace Conference, he feared politicians would smash the remnants beyond repair. With the disaster of the Great Depression, and the rise of totalitarianism, there was no doubt civilisation was on the brink. It’s a more perilous picture than a search for the “good life”, and a more profound struggle.

The play, so immersed in Bloomsbury, inevitably underplays this. The Arts Council is not the culminating achievement of Keynes’ life, even if his artistic friends (or a modern West End audience) think so. In fairness, I doubt they did. (I’d add I received a major Arts Council award myself, once upon a time, for a novel that still languishes unloved. I’m very grateful but … well, perspective!) 

Yes, Keynes was humane and loved the arts. But both the social safety net of the Beveridge Report and the benevolence of the Arts Council (ensuring Merry England made merry in its own way, and death to Hollywood, as he disarmingly observed) were still side issues, compared to creating the tools that would keep the world economy from dysfunction and collapse.

But that’s my interpretation – and maybe my own projection?

CHASING GHOSTS

It’s a peculiar thing to rummage in somebody’s life and construct a version for one’s own purposes. Would Keynes have even approved? I’ve often (rather guiltily) asked myself this. He never gave interviews, and after his death his widow, Lydia, was even more private: she refused to engage with his biographers or attend events to aggrandise his memory. She was happy to let her own by-its-nature ephemeral stage career pass away unrecorded.

Yet Keynes was aware of the power of phantoms. “Practical men, who believe themselves to be quite exempt from any intellectual influences, are usually the slaves of some defunct economist,” he wrote, and ideas don’t live on only in the pages of academic journals but in the stories of their originators. Whatever fictional version of Keynes is the most true to the man himself (and he was a man who changed his ideas like quicksilver: “when the facts change, I change my mind” he claimed . He wanted his ideas to have an impact on the world.

Recreating Keynes through the imagination, in myriad ways and forms, is one way of making that happen – and in times that are coming to seem as fragile as his own.

POSTSCRIPT
After I wrote this, I went to look at others’ reviews of the play. . . I notice that many reviewers think too much was crammed in: with which I agree. I seem to be alone, though, in disliking the emphasis on Hayek. I was also intrigued that Bloomsbury seemed to inspire quite so much disdain: I wonder if this is because Keynes’ story puts them in a particularly bad light (which it definitely does) or if their general appeal is waning? Exciting Bohemian progressives or just tiresome, self-absorbed snobs?

Finally I’d add that the first person to fictionalize Keynes seems to have been John Buchan, who knew Keynes and disliked him. I haven’t read those yet but I’m certainly looking forward to it!

E.J.BARNES


                        


This post, with full links, and earlier articles on other topics, appears on Substack
See : E.J.Barnes @ ejbarnes : Economical With Fiction. Interested in 1920's, 1930's, JMKeynes, Bloomsbury, political economy, 20th century writers, forgotten classis, science v religion, social history, kids books. Writer of Historical Fiction.

Thank you, Emma!



                                  THE MAYNARD KEYNES NOVELS by E.J.BARNES

 
        
MR KEYNES REVOLUTION
“Since the war, everything’s changed. The powers-that-be hold to the old mantras … but how far can you push people? Until they rise up and throw the government down?”

When the brilliant and mercurial Maynard Keynes walks out on the Paris Peace Conference, he seems destined for obscurity. But in the crisis-ridden 1920s, he soon finds himself back on the public stage. A man of fierce intelligence and hidden susceptibilities, he is not afraid to speak the truth to a political elite blindly determined to push the world to the brink of collapse.

Dancer Lydia Lopokova has fled revolution and is now seeking her own personal salvation. The last thing she expects is a life-changing encounter with a Bohemian economist. In a divided world where neither their Bloomsbury friends nor the powerful elites seem to realise the dangers, their encounter will have long-reaching consequences. (Longlisted for the Peggy Chapman-Andrews Novel Award/Bridport Prize.)

MR KEYNES DANCE

The sequel to the much-praised Mr Keynes’ Revolution follows Maynard and Lydia into the 1930s and the challenges of political turmoil and the Great Depression.

1926. Maynard Keynes has long been a thorn in the side of the British Establishment: an irritant to the Treasury, the Bank of England and his fellow academics alike. Rejected for his radical ideas, he has made an unlikely marriage to a Russian ballerina, her eccentricity charming him almost as much as it infuriates his highbrow Bloomsbury friends. But as the world around them changes, Maynard and Lydia cannot stay cocooned in their private refuge for long.

While Maynard frets about the ever-growing dole queues, and plans his route to power by way of the magnetic Lloyd George, Lydia is tormented by the thought of her family in Leningrad. Exiled by the Russian Revolution, she has found fame and fortune as the star dancer of Diaghilev’s celebrated Ballets Russes. Yet however demanding the role of stage celebrity, it is less challenging than that of the supposedly respectable and fortunate Mrs Keynes: the scrutiny of a crowded theatre less intense than from those convinced her marriage is heading for disaster. In truth for Lydia and Maynard, marriage was always a gamble, and their life a dance where nobody is ever quite sure of the steps.

Then comes the Wall Street Crash, followed by a depression the likes of which the world has never seen. In the turmoil of the 1930s, the intellectual Maynard finds that answers must be sought in the most unlikely places.

Set during some of the most momentous years of the twentieth century, this novel explores the lives of two figures at the heart of those economic and cultural upheavals: John Maynard Keynes, considered by many as the most important economist of all time, and one of Time Magazine’s most significant people of the twentieth century, and the celebrated and eccentric Russian ballerina, Lydia Lopokova. Beginning in the “roaring twenties”, with ever-growing unemployment queues and a General Strike that pitches the whole labouring class against the governing elite, their journey takes them from the heart of the Bohemian Bloomsbury Group in Sussex, to Leningrad in Soviet Russia, to New York in the grip of the Great Depression, to the quiet colleges courts of Cambridge. The supporting cast ranges from a Welsh kitchen maid to pioneering socialist Beatrice Webb, fascist leader Oswald Mosley, politician Winston Churchill and writer Virginia Woolf.

A sequel to Mr Keynes’ Revolution, which was much praised for the depth of its research, and the way it deftly interwove economic ideas and history into a story of personal relationships and romance, Mr Keynes’ Dance is another intellectually daring and page-turning historical novel, which continues the tumultuous and surprising story of Maynard and Lydia.



Thank you, Emma.  https://ejbarnesauthor.com/

Posted on the History Girls by Penny Dolan